Fixing the Online Conversational Space
- January 27th, 2006
- Write comment
I am increasingly frustrated by the structure of discourse on the Internet. I’m not talking about grammar or rhetoric or anything like that. I’m talking about how exchanges that happen between the various people involved in a “thread” are displayed onscreen. There are lots of ways to represent a thread. None of them are any good. Time for a new one that gives the reader an ability to contextualize by reference backward in a manner whereby everything stays on the screen.
Right now we tend to display threads in vertical space only. We have dynamic nesting, but that is still just a collapse of verticality. Why not a combination of vertical and horizontal? Kind of like the Mac Finder file view that shows directories side-by-side and files listed vertically. Eventually one would scroll off the screen horizontally if a thread went deep enough. but I think it would be gain for online discussions if an original post or posts occupied the first vertical column, responses the second, responses to responses the third, etc. All these columns can scroll vertically so the referent comment is always on screen. Also, like the Mac finder view, the last column is always refering back to a single comment in the column previous. Narrow columns are not a problem since it is proven we read better that way (think newspapers).
I’ll conclude by saying I don’t know how to do this. Some trick of javascript and CSS positioning might do. One would need to be able to load and change the contents of a single page dynamically. I’ve seen an ability to do this on DKOS, for exmaple.
Any ideas anyone?